May 11, 2026 • 46 min • Season 5, Episode 11
Guests: Nathan Harwit
Unscripted solo commentary + game review takeaways + lesson recap • Beginner to Intermediate
Episode Summary
Travis shares updates about upcoming All Things Go collaborations, including a Star Point crossover, an interview with Jonas Welticke, and live commentary with Gabe from Strugglebus Go. He then reflects on a birthday game review with Nico (Tuerda), using it to explore weak groups, running toward safety, good and bad shape, and the value of pattern recognition. The episode closes with lesson takeaways from Nathan Harwit on cutting, liberty counting, cognitive load, plateaus, and practical improvement.
Episode Overview
- Upcoming collaborations with Star Point, Jonas Welticke, and the San Diego Go Championship commentary team.
- A birthday game review with Nico (Tuerda) focused on weak groups, running, connection, and survival.
- How experienced players recognize good and bad shape before they can fully explain it.
- Why rating plateaus and losing streaks can hide real improvement.
- Nathan Harwit’s lesson takeaways on cuts, liberties, shape, and reducing cognitive overload.
Main Topics
- Star Point collaboration
- Go commentary
- Game review
- Weak groups and running
- Good and bad shape
- Pattern recognition
- Rating plateaus
- Cuts and liberties
- Cognitive load
Practical Lesson Takeaways
- When a weak group must run, move directly toward a genuinely safe connection rather than making slow shape along the way.
- Use the weakest-group principle to decide whether to strengthen your own stones or attack the opponent.
- Treat “that does not look right” as an early pattern-recognition signal, then investigate the concrete reason.
- During difficult positions, simplify the mental task by counting liberties and identifying the most urgent cut or connection.
- Judge progress over a meaningful sample of games rather than reacting to a short losing streak or rating dip.
Notable Insights
- Pattern recognition often appears before conscious verbal explanation; review converts intuition into reusable understanding.
- A plateau can reflect experimentation, stronger opposition, or newly developing skills rather than stagnation.
- Good shape is not a decorative concept; it coordinates liberties, connection, efficiency, and future options.
Recommended Audience
Beginner and intermediate players; Listeners interested in game-review takeaways; Players struggling with shape, liberty counting, or rating plateaus; Fans of unscripted podcast updates
Links & Resources
Full Transcript
Read the full transcript
This transcript has been lightly edited for clarity. Timestamps correspond to the published episode.
Opening Sponsor Acknowledgment
[00:00] Travis: This episode is sponsored by BadukPop and SmartGo One.
Podcast Updates and Upcoming Collaborations
[00:27] Travis: Hey, everybody. I hope you’ve been having a great week. I hope you’ve been able to get some Go in during your last week. I can start by talking about the fact that I did get to play a game of Go in real life on my birthday, which was really fun. I played again with my buddy Adam, and we had a great time. And I also got to review the game with somebody, which was really fun. And I had some really interesting takeaways about it that I don’t yet have as real concepts. I mean, I have them in my brain when I think about playing Go, but this review helped me think about them from a different angle, so I’ll touch on that in a little bit. So the first thing up is that I have a nice calendar coming up over the next week or two, and I apologize if I’m being redundant, and I’ve mentioned these before, but I have a few exciting things that I’m looking forward to recording for the show.
[01:29] Travis: And the first one is that on top of me meeting with my Go teacher, Nathan Harwit, and I’ll definitely be recording those takeaways. You’ll hear that at the end of this episode. I will also be talking with Jonas Welticke, the German Go champion who runs the Reading Dojo. And I’m really looking forward to talking to him because he has this really interesting approach around visualization and remembering positions and really building your ability to see things in your mind’s eye, which I think is really fascinating. So I’m looking forward to that conversation. We have scheduled that next week. The other thing is that I actually connected with Justin over at Star Point, and as I mentioned before, we wanted to do a brainstorming session. So we did one over this past week and we just said, hey, like, what could we connect on that might be fun to do? And I think we effectively landed on really just doing an interview of the other person. So I will interview him this coming week for All Things Go.
[02:40] Travis: And then in the weeks following, he’ll interview me for Star Point, and then we will look to try to release those at the same time just to make it fun. So, yeah, it was really fun crafting questions for Justin just because I’m obviously sitting in a similar seat to what he’s doing. We’re both running podcasts, so it was fun to think about, like, how to ask him those questions, what to ask him. So stay tuned for that. I’m hoping that’ll be a lot of fun. The other thing that’s happening is that in the United States, in the city of San Diego, California, they are hosting their 15th annual Go Championship. And Enrique, who I believe is the president of the club there, has been nice enough to ask me to come and commentate for the first round of those championships. And I’m going to be doing it with Gabe from Strugglebus Go.
[03:41] Travis: If you’re familiar with his YouTube channel, he does awesome videos for double-digit kyu and low single-digit kyu folks like myself. So that’ll be really fun. I’m looking forward to doing that. And if you just want an excuse to listen to some people talk about Go, that will be there. I think what we’re going to be doing, like what we did with the California championship last year that I did with Justin at Star Point, is that we’re going to really just be focusing on beginner stuff. Right. If anybody’s watching it and they don’t know anything about Go, how do you think about the game? What are some key concepts? We’re not going to get into things in great depth, but that’ll be really fun. I actually really enjoyed that experience last time. I didn’t think I would have nearly enough for me and my co-host to talk about and it felt as though a few hours went by in a flash.
[04:41] Travis: Yeah, so stay tuned for that if you have any interest in tuning in to that if you’ve been listening to the show. I think it was back in season two or three that I got to interview Jonathan Hop, who wrote the So You Think You Can Play Go series of books. I might be butchering the exact titling, but he wrote two or three books about how to play Go, from a low double-digit kyu level to a higher level and then to a dan-level player. And he also has the website Sunday Go Lessons. And Jonathan had been, I think less involved in sort of the Go world for the past however many years. But he had that website and I did use it some years ago and when I interviewed him it was really fun to kind of retrace his path and his steps in the Go world and all the things he’s done. But the website was actually really quite nice. I actually enjoyed it quite a bit.
[05:43] Travis: And Jonathan just made a post on the r/baduk subreddit about him revamping the website and I think he’s trying to incorporate AI to some degree and large language models in making that process more helpful for people learning Go and improving. So I’m looking forward to that. Jonathan’s been nice enough to give me some kind of early access to just play around with it and give feedback. I’m sure he’s open to other people doing it too. And so, yeah, I’m looking forward to getting in there and diving in and connecting back with him. So Jonathan, thank you so much for letting me do that. And who knows, perhaps it could lead to a follow-up conversation for the show. So that was another thing.
Birthday Game and Review with Nico “Tuerda”
[06:32] Travis: Now I want to touch base on that birthday game of Go I played, I think it was last week. And on top of it being really fun, I always have a great time with Adam. He’s a great conversationalist and we’ve also found that like our worlds are very small. He actually ran into my mother-in-law at an event locally and sent a picture which was hilarious. So it was just cool to see that. But we played a game and we’re both, you know, on the Online Go Server, we’re somewhere around 9-kyu to 11-kyu. It’s kind of hard to tell to be honest, but we are very similarly paired in terms of our strength. So we played the game, and then I was able to connect with someone who I did interview back a few seasons ago, Nico, who goes by “Tuerda” and is a moderator on the r/baduk subreddit.
[07:31] Travis: He was just really nice to kind of do a game review with me and go through the game. And it was really helpful because obviously I have my Go teacher. But you know, Go is a game that is so complex and abstract that it absolutely benefits from getting many perspectives. And I think any of us that have been involved with the game for more than a little bit know that. And so it was really refreshing to get that perspective. And so I’m going to just touch on that because in the game something that happened early on is that I was playing Black, Adam was playing White and we got into a fight fairly early in the game. We played out a standard joseki in one corner of the board and then in the other corner White attached to my stone. And I played a cutting move pretty early and so it led to this fight. And so Nico was really just diving in with me.
[08:39] Travis: One point he highlighted—something I understood, but began to understand better as we reviewed the game—was to think of the board as a desert. As soon as you put stones down, assume that nothing is alive until you make it alive. There are two basic ways to do that. You can eventually make two eyes—or capture the opponent’s surrounding group, which also gives you two eyes—or you can run and connect to another group of yours that is already alive. In the fight that erupted early in my game, it was helpful to see that principle play out.
[09:42] Travis: My opponent and I were both missing important things happening on the board, such as which group we should strengthen or attack. I have always kept the idea “play toward the weakest group” in mind, and this review reinforced how important that is. If your group is the weakest on the board, strengthen it. If your opponent’s group is weak, attack it. The concept of running was especially helpful because it was something I was missing. I had a group getting surrounded on both sides, and I tried to attack one of White’s groups. It did not work; White escaped. I was left with two weak groups and was simply trying to run, survive, and get away. I was already quite far behind.
[10:41] Travis: And it was really interesting to see Nico explain to me, like, hey, you are running, but what you’re doing along the way is you’re trying to make these shape moves to, like, almost make space to make eyes later, when the reality is you just want to actually be running towards your other Black stone that’s on the other part of the board. But what I was actually doing was starting to run not exactly in the direction of where that other stone was. And I was trying to play kind of not as fast, not extend as far and trying to make more shape and size along the way, which I think was hurting me. And so that was really interesting. I had not really internalized that concept, as simple as it sounds. It’s like, oh, right, like, you should be running towards that other stone. So once I had that point of reference in this game review, it really changed how I looked at what I was playing in the game. And it was like, oh, interesting.
[11:42] Travis: I was running and trying to escape as White surrounded me on every side, but I was letting White get between me and the other Black stone I needed to connect to on the other side of the board. And so that wasn’t really helping. So I think Nico thought it wasn’t a revolutionary idea. But again, it’s like, you know, human nature, right? Like we need to hear these things over and over again in different ways for it to really click. And I’m sure there’ll be way more that clicks in my brain because I’m at the level I’m at. But it was really helpful. So that was exciting and maybe that helps a few of you out there that are at my level. So that was fun.
Sponsor Message
[12:23] Travis: This episode is sponsored by BadukPop, the app that makes learning Go fun and accessible with interactive puzzles, bite-sized lessons, and an AI tutor to guide you step by step. It is perfect for players on the move. You can download it or learn more at badukpop.com. That is B-A-D-U-K-P-O-P dot com. This episode is also sponsored by SmartGo One, the all-in-one Go toolkit for Apple devices. Replay professional games, solve problems, and keep your SGF collection organized in one elegant app. Check it out at smartgo.com or wherever you get your apps.
Cognition, Pattern Recognition, and Go
[13:03] Travis: As you know, I have my fun podcast that I listen to throughout the week when I’m driving to work or I’m doing groceries or whatever it might be, or I’m going for a walk and I keep going back to these ones that often tie into topics around cognition. And one line came up in a recent podcast that just struck me and made me think about Go. And it said that when you think about our brains and how they are made to work, they are not naturally built to be doing a lot of high-level thinking because this would burn a lot of metabolic energy and because our sort of history, our evolution as a species is to really actually have a lot of habits, instincts, and muscle memories so that we are efficient with our energy and our thinking. We’re not really made to do that level of difficult processing with our brains.
[14:05] Travis: And that really just made me think about cognition more broadly. But of course it made me think about Go. Because when we play Go, we’re very much trying to do that active thinking. But we also have pattern recognition, depending on how much we have played the game. And we are trying to find that balance of efficiency of pieces on the board, the efficiency of trade-offs: points or territory gained or lost, and strength gained or lost. And so that just hit home for me.
Good Shape and “That Does Not Look Right” Moments
[14:38] Travis: The other thing I wanted to touch on was just going into r/baduk, the subreddit, there’s been some new player questions, some of which are pretty standard around, like, how do I count this board? We think we played our first game, how do I count it? Which is hard to describe on an audio podcast, but there are some other ones that came up. One was from somebody named Rick Ziski, who asked, “What are some of your ‘that does not look right’ moments?” And I thought it was a fun question. And they were just saying like, hey, I’ve had several years of experience as a chess player and I realized chess and Go are different. But I was curious about one aspect of learning the game, and one of the hallmarks of chess improvement is developing an intuition for what standard play looks like and then developing knowledge to punish your opponent when they’re not doing that.
[15:34] Travis: And so this person was asking, like, what are some of those analogous moments in Go and when, you know, an opponent makes too many, you know, inappropriate moves, attaches too much, all those sorts of things, like, what do you think about that? And yeah, some of the higher-ranked players kind of responded and said like, well, yeah, I mean, at one level there’s just this concept of bad shape and good shape is something that was so foreign to me in the beginning. I mean, I knew that, okay, there’s the one-space jump, there’s the diagonal, right? You can use Japanese terminology for these things, all that sort of stuff. But it was interesting to me that when I found myself trying to describe this to my dad, because we actually got to play a little bit of Go the other night,
[16:31] Travis: Later that night, It was just a nice excuse for us to connect and talk and chat. But we also put on a 13-by-13 game online. I was trying to explain to him that concept of shape, good and bad shape. And it was interesting for me to try to articulate it because it was really effectively saying, hey, if you put the stones arranged in a certain pattern on the board, later, if your opponent tries to cut through them or tries to do anything with them, or you’re trying to, you know, finish territory on the board, some shapes hold up really, really well. They are very efficient and accomplish many things, while other shapes are just bad, right? And I think better players or players who have played Go for a long time, they can just recognize what is good shape and what is bad shape.
[17:17] Travis: And all these teaching games that I’ve been mentioning that I’ve been playing with people that have been really nice to play with me that are much higher in rank. I’ve been seeing this where they are playing moves locally where it looks very innocuous, like almost nothing is being done. But then later in the game we get to the end game and it’s like, oh, wow, wait a second. That simple move you played actually really reduced my ability to have a base and also protected your shape in case I tried to play, you know, a move back. It is really interesting how your understanding of shape develops over time. The basic idea sounds simple, but applying it is easier said than done.
Plateaus, Losing Streaks, and Rating Progress
[18:09] Travis: Another newer player posted that they felt as though they were getting worse rather than better. The username was inuzuna—I-N-U-Z-U-N-A, if I am pronouncing it correctly. They wrote, “Maybe I am just in a slump I need to get over. Or maybe all my wins in the past have just been flukes, but it seems like no matter what I do, I am stuck where I am. I have lost enough games to drop from 19-kyu to 21-kyu and have barely been able to climb back. I know I need to work on a lot of things, but it feels like what little talent I have in the game has faded away. I really do not know what to do, because the videos and books I have do not seem to be cutting it.”
[18:57] Travis: I kind of appreciate these posts because I think I feel this way a lot where I’m just like, gosh, I’m not getting anywhere, I’m not moving in my rank, or I don’t feel like I’m improving. And that may or may not correspond to rank. And sometimes we just need a little bit of support from the community, like, hey, hang in there, like, you’ll be okay. And so maybe that’s you right now. Maybe you’re feeling a similar way wherever you are in your rank journey and you’re just like, gosh, I’m not breaking through, I’m plateauing. So yeah, r/baduk is always a great place to get some of that support and just looking at some of the responses here, there were some good ones. The one username here, pp2tiny, I think we all can understand what that means. They wrote, “At first you play with complete ignorance and blissfully stumble into good shape.” Again, that ties back to the other post about good shape.
[19:57] Travis: I totally get that. Yeah, I definitely stumble into good shape. And then the response continues: “As you start to understand more, you overthink and analyze situations that may or may not be helpful in your game and so you tend to lose more. Then once you understand more and more situations, you overthink less and start understanding more and so your gameplay drastically improves. Be patient; it will come.” I do definitely think there’s this concept that like you, once you make a breakthrough in something, you don’t immediately get better. Especially with a complex game like Go, you figure it out and you say, oh wow, I’m playing too many moves. That’s reducing aji, right? Like maybe I had a stone that was deep in enemy territory and I played too close to it now and I’ve erased the opportunity to use it later.
[20:47] Travis: You might not see that you’re all of a sudden, you know, winning prolifically because you figured that out, right? Against people of a certain rank, it just takes time. It’s so interesting how nonlinear that path towards improvement or even showing it in your rank comes through. By the way, I think I mentioned this last week and I was saying that I really did want to get Nikola Tsarigradski, who was on the show in Season Four to talk about Go rating systems because Nikola was really knowledgeable about it. He’s going to come back on. So he agreed and he’s going to come back on and just talk a little bit more about the OGS system, why there might be discrepancies there in rank that can and cannot be controlled. And then he also has some interesting developments around what he’s doing. He’s now part of the European Go Federation’s Rating Commission. So it’ll be really interesting to talk to him and have him back. So stay tuned for that.
[21:55] Travis: And then I do really like this point in this post about winning and losing. I’ve heard this from a few different people I really respect in the Go community, which is they say that sometimes you look at how much somebody is winning and losing when you play a game and sometimes you try to infer from that, oh wow, if I am losing against these players and I’m losing by 10 points every game, that means I am, you know, one stone weaker, right? Or something like this. Other times you have it where it’s a blowout, right? You play somebody and you lose by 60 points. Right? A huge number. And I am starting to appreciate now, mostly because of those around me in the community that have been playing this game much longer than I have, that that point differential at the end of games doesn’t always necessarily tell you a whole lot about the rank difference or the strength difference between you and your opponent.
[22:56] Travis: And the reason is that sometimes you could be in a very tight battle or fight with an opponent, and then whoever comes out winning on that results in a huge, you know, win or loss of territory in the game. So again, having that huge swing may not mean that, you know, you’re much weaker than that opponent. Likewise, you could have a whole lot of games where you’re only five points different, but you always lose that game. You might have a significant strength or skill level difference there. So I guess the moral of the story is that point differentials are not always as helpful as I think we hope they could be. But, I mean, this is how it goes. If you want a game that is rich and that will have you learning constantly throughout your life, which is what I love about the game, and I think a lot of you do too, this complexity is part of what makes it possible. There’s just so many aspects to that game.
[23:53] Travis: There’s so many parts of it. And so you have to kind of find your ways to get support, to keep yourself upbeat, talk with others in the community when you’re feeling bummed out. But remember, at the end of the day, it is just a game. We’re just doing this for fun, for the puzzle of it. So I’m just looking through some of the other responses to this post. GoGabeGo, who runs Strugglebus Go, wrote, “Go can be very swingy. At the end of the day, your record is going to average out to roughly 50% wins and 50% losses. Sometimes that comes in the form of losing 10 in a row and then going two wins, one loss for your next 30 games. Not to belittle losing streaks. They truly suck and are very demoralizing. Just know that it happens to all of us.” Amen. Definitely does.
Go Lesson Takeaways with Nathan Harwit: Cuts, Liberties, and Cognitive Load
[24:46] Travis: Okay, so with that, I’m going to transition us over to my lesson takeaway with Nathan Harwit, my Go teacher. And after that, we’ll wrap up the episode. So thanks so much for listening. Have a great week. Go play some Go. Get through whatever is happening in your life, whether it is an intense period at work or in your personal life, and try to find ways to bring the game into your life in the ways you can. So thanks so much, and we’ll jump over to the lesson takeaway now. So, Nathan, we’re here. There were two games that we reviewed. One was the game I played in real life for my birthday with Adam. And let’s just recap what you kind of saw there. I started with the fight. I started with a cut in the bottom right corner early in the game, and things kind of propelled forward. What did you see as the main thing that my friend and I were missing?
[25:49] Nathan Harwit: Yeah, the main takeaway was checking for cuts and groups with low liberties. It is often not that hard to read them. It’s basically just, okay, atari is a forcing move. And then, oh, that sets up a double atari or, oh, if I cut here, then both groups are at two liberties and then stuff starts falling apart for the opponent. I saw that theme in at least three places in that game, where it had to do with cuts and just low liberties in general.
[26:16] Travis: Right?
[26:16] Nathan Harwit: Yeah.
[26:17] Travis: Right. I am quickly scanning through the game, and obviously the audience cannot see it. The first example is in the bottom-right corner. I play the cut, creating four groups. You have told me many times that counting liberties, when you do not yet have the intuition, will help reveal where you need to play and what is happening. Adam and I are both somewhere around 10-kyu on OGS. I sometimes count liberties, but I am still not doing it consistently or clearly. There are four weak groups around this cut, and one of them is my Black group in the corner.
[27:10] Travis: That Black group is in serious trouble very quickly because we were both so focused on the other groups: I was trying to kill one of White’s groups, and Adam was trying to protect it. That is the first example. Then there was another moment in the bottom-right corner, after I tried to create a little eye space. You said, “Travis, count the liberties.” If White cuts, one separated Black group has only two liberties, and the other group also has only two. You laid it out plainly, but for some reason we simply were not looking at it.
[28:17] Travis: We were just not looking at it. We just weren’t even paying attention.
[28:20] Nathan Harwit: Yeah, that is pretty common. I mean, it even happens to stronger players where it’s like, okay, you see this big fight, and then it’s like, oh, there’s a couple open corners, too. So it’s like, yeah, a little bit different than that, but it’s like, yeah, tunnel vision’s a real thing, and it makes sense. So sometimes taking a step back and saying, “Let me check these groups. Check the liberties. How close are they to the edge of the board?” The closer they are to the edge, the weaker they are, generally, because they can’t really run past the edge of the board. Oh, yeah, I guess you asked about the other two spots, right? Or was there another one?
[28:53] Travis: There were two other examples, although we do not need to describe both explicitly. One was in the middle of the board. My attack had gone horribly, two strong White groups were coming after me, and I was trying to outrun them like a tidal wave. Along the way I tried to make eye space, and White tried to block me in. White played one line away from the expected point, leaving stones above and below, plus a lot of apparent liberties. You pointed to the one stone that had been played differently and asked, “How many liberties does that stone have?” The answer was two.
[29:45] Travis: Two liberties. So it allowed the opportunity for me, as Black, to play a move to at least get one of their stones in atari and then try to sort of outrun them and cut them in that direction.
[29:59] Nathan Harwit: Yeah, yeah. Basically, there are three stones in a diagonal row.
[30:02] Travis: That’s right.
[30:03] Nathan Harwit: There are some more stones, but that cut is fairly common and especially if you count and you’re like, hey, I’m actually losing. You can kind of go for a kind of all-or-nothing variation there because you are going to lose anyway if you do not try it.
[30:16] Travis: Right. And I saw it, but way too late in the game, I thought to make much of it. You saw it much earlier. I cannot help but connect this to something I mentioned earlier in this episode. I was talking about the fact that I was listening to somebody talk on a podcast about like cognitive science and that our brains, like evolutionarily, are made to try to do as little thinking as possible. Like, we are supposedly evolved to try to make things as habitual or automatic as possible because that would actually preserve energy. Because, like, we burn a ton of energy with our brains. We have a huge brain. What I’m getting to, and it’s not an excuse, but I do think what happens is like, these games are 250 moves. They can be a lot of moves. I know for a fact that I am trying to consciously and unconsciously choose where I start to burn energy. And do you have any thoughts or reactions on that?
[31:21] Nathan Harwit: Yeah, I mean, basically a lot of what I recommend to save your energy is just play your standard opening. Pick the same opening play at every game. So you free up cognitive capacity. Like if you like Chinese opening, sanrensei, whatever. I think it’s called fisheye, where it’s like two 3-4 points facing each other, whatever it is. Or like always double star point as white or whatever. Then it’s like, okay, you’ve played that specific opening so many times, you free up all your cognitive ability. You can do more counting later in the game because you’re not as tired. You can scan the board for all these cuts more often. Kind of think more strategically instead of trying to brute-force every single variation. A lot of it is also that stronger players have just generally a better intuition, so they free up a lot of their cognitive ability and they don’t have to like check these kind of things that some weaker players might still need to check through explicit reading.
[32:20] Travis: Right. And that’s what always is like, so frustrating as a non-dan player, I’m like, wow. Like, they’re just seeing that so quickly.
[32:27] Nathan Harwit: Right.
[32:28] Travis: You see them quickly now, but there was a stage when you did not and had to read them out. In my next correspondence game, I am literally going to write down: whenever a new cut appears, count the liberties of every group. It is not that I think I am above doing that; it is simply a cognitive-load issue. I like the idea of keeping parts of the opening constant so that I can save energy. We also looked at another teaching game against someone around 2-dan on OGS, and once again you were emphasizing cuts.
[33:25] Travis: And what happens, particularly when we cut on what I think is the second line?
[33:31] Nathan Harwit: Yep.
[33:32] Travis: You have been talking about how those cuts can be dangerous. Um, and it’s been a pretty nebulous thing. Like, it’s hard for me to always see, like, why it’s dangerous. But let me just go to that really quickly.
[33:45] Nathan Harwit: Yeah, it’s actually gonna be usually third line. I might’ve said second line.
[33:48] Travis: Third line. No, no, thank you. Thank you.
[33:50] Nathan Harwit: You’re right.
[33:51] Travis: Third line—excuse me. I was Black, with one group in the lower middle and another in the lower right, while White had stones between them. We were moving into the endgame, and I was trying to reduce White’s moyo. I played a second-line move on the lower-right side that cut into the moyo. You helped me play out the sequence: Black cuts on the third line; White blocks on the second line; Black cuts; White extends along the second line; and then Black extends in the other direction to gain liberties. At that point you said, “Let us count: whose turn is it, and how many liberties does each group have?”
[34:55] Travis: Holding the liberty counts of all four groups in my head was admittedly difficult. We then asked where Black could play after the cut to keep pressuring White. Toward my Black group in the middle, there was a possible push and cut. The question was when to activate it. You made a broader point about comparing a group near the edge of the board with one farther toward the center, even when they have the same number of liberties. Can you restate that?
[35:49] Nathan Harwit: Yeah, this is a really big one. I see a lot of mistakes regarding it just in terms of reading. Because fights create a lot of cognitive load. Even up to roughly 5-kyu, it’s like a very, very common mistake. It’s basically when you’re at two liberties near the edge of the board, you are going to die nine times out of ten unless you kill the other guy first. But it’s just like two liberties. There’s a lot less flexibility. There’s not much you can really do, especially on the edge where you just can’t make more liberties. You’re on the edge of the board. Second line, you can’t really run away. So that’s kind of like a reading trick. Even before reading every variation, it’s like, oh, actually they’re going to be at two liberties. They’re just going to die.
[36:32] Travis: Does that rule always apply when a group has two liberties, Nathan? Or could it even be like my group is toward the middle of the board. I have three liberties, their group also has three liberties, but they’re on the edge of the board. So therefore you’re like, hey, nine times out of ten that’s going to be dicier for the group near the edge.
[36:49] Nathan Harwit: Yeah, yeah. It also applies at three liberties. My general rule of thumb is that two liberties near the edge of the board usually means dead. Three liberties near the edge of the board still means very weak. You can still oftentimes kill them. It will not be nine out of ten times. It might be like six or seven out of ten times. You’ve got a really good sequence that just kills them.
[37:07] Travis: Right? Yeah.
[37:08] Nathan Harwit: Generally, once you get past three liberties and you’re at like four, even if you’re near the edge of the board, you’re generally going to be okay more than half the time. Three is the point where the group is getting weak, so you want to double-check, but at two, it is usually disastrous.
[37:23] Travis: You then showed me the one-space extension I could make after the cut. It kept White pressed against the second line on the right side. Each time I worried that White could push and cut through the one-space jump, you had me play out the cut and count again. Over and over, White’s group on the side fell back to two liberties, even when my own groups had only two or three.
[38:11] Nathan Harwit: Right. Before the move, the groups had roughly two and three liberties. After you play, your groups can have three and three while White’s groups fall to two and two.
[38:21] Travis: So I see two main takeaways. First, keep parts of the opening consistent to reduce cognitive load. Second, whenever there is a cut—or I am considering one—read a few moves, then literally count the liberties of every group. At around 10-kyu down to 5-kyu on OGS, my intuition is not yet reliable enough to do that automatically. I know the general rule to play toward the weaker group after a cut, but this adds another layer, does it not?
[39:13] Nathan Harwit: Yeah, this one, you have to balance your own liberties and also check theirs. So it’s like you have to do it kind of twice. Because it’s like, in this case, it’s like, oh, yeah, you’ve got some weak stones, but instead of defending yourself, you can just go ahead and kill them first, which defends you better because they die.
[39:28] Travis: There is also a bigger-picture layer. In the second teaching game, we examined a nearby push-and-cut sequence that could immediately weaken the opponent’s group. You showed me that by around 5-kyu and into the dan ranks, players are less likely simply to lose those stones. Their intuition about liberty differences and cuts is stronger. The position becomes more about reading life-and-death and choosing trades. A stronger opponent would not simply give up a large group of stones.
[40:17] Travis: Instead, the opponent might sacrifice a different group or accept that I have reduced the moyo somewhat, rather than lose everything. At my level, we are often not yet considering that larger trade-off.
[40:35] Nathan Harwit: Right. It comes back to cognitive load. I do not want to teach all five steps while we are still working on steps one and two. You have to build the understanding in layers.
[40:47] Travis: So you could almost make this a whole exercise of like, how do I reduce cognitive load as much as possible?
[40:53] Nathan Harwit: Yeah.
[40:53] Travis: In a game, are there any other tricks to do that?
[40:57] Nathan Harwit: One trick is you spam games because you see the same thing so many times. Your brain’s like, I remember that kind of thing. I’m just gonna do this. And it usually works. Because you have seen it so many times. You know what tends to work and what does not. That is one approach.
[41:11] Travis: So you could just watch or quickly play through many games, noticing the openings and interesting positions.
[41:19] Nathan Harwit: Another, more active method is to watch a lot of pro games or just like stronger players than you, even if you’re around 10-kyu, watching a 1-dan is pretty good too. You would actively try to predict where the moves are that the players are going to play and you try to figure out why they’re playing it. And then that way in your own games, you’ll start seeing some of the shapes probably and that reduces cognitive load because you already thought about it in someone else’s game.
[41:46] Travis: That’s a really good point. Would it be helpful to watch on something where I could also click and see the AI move? At my level, it’s tricky, right? Because like I often, I’d say maybe half the time I kind of understand what the move is, but the other half I don’t.
[42:02] Nathan Harwit: Yeah, I mean, at your rank, it can help to have the AI available, because a 1-dan is not going to play perfect moves, and neither is a 9-dan. You can use it as a reference. You can be like, oh, they played a really good move. It was the third-best AI move. And I also would have played somewhere near there because they’re only playing one move at a time. You might have picked a move that was better than their move, but you wouldn’t know because you would assume their move is best if you didn’t have the AI on, for example.
[42:28] Travis: Hmm. And if I simply do not understand it, I should probably set it aside and recognize that it is not helping me right now.
[42:35] Nathan Harwit: Exactly. If you look at a recommendation and think, “I do not understand what the AI is doing,” focus on something more straightforward. The move may be beyond what is currently the most efficient use of your study time. It is not an absolute rule—some difficult moves are still worth investigating—but you do not need to chase every recommendation you cannot explain.
[43:02] Travis: One last question before we go: after I play a game, is it basically a no-brainer that I should review it myself first and then review it with AI?
[43:19] Nathan Harwit: Yes. First go through the game yourself and identify what you think could have been improved. Once you turn on the AI, it is easy to say, “Of course I should have played there.” You need to record what you actually noticed before seeing the machine’s answers.
[43:43] Travis: You have to remember your thought process and the case you were making for a move. Is there a risk that reviewing it yourself first could cement an incorrect way of thinking before you consult AI or talk to a teacher? The broader question is how much time should pass before you consult a teacher, a stronger player, or AI?
[44:04] Nathan Harwit: Yeah, I mean, there are problems both ways. I would say it’s a lot worse to just turn the AI on without thinking about it.
[44:11] Travis: Yeah.
[44:12] Nathan Harwit: Otherwise, you can look at the answer and say, “I would have gone there; of course I knew that.” It is like seeing the answers before taking the test. Active recall is much harder—and much more useful—than simply looking at all the AI answers.
[44:28] Travis: That is a really good point. Otherwise I see the blue move—the best move—but may have no idea why it is good. I am no longer thinking; I am just looking at an answer.
[44:38] Nathan Harwit: Yeah, yeah, exactly.
[44:40] Travis: Yeah, great, Nathan. Really, really helpful as always.
[44:45] Nathan Harwit: Yeah, it’s fun.
Sponsor Message
[45:00] Travis: On a final note, I want to thank our sponsors again. SmartGo One is your all-in-one Go toolkit for iPhone, iPad, and Mac. Whether you are replaying games, solving problems, or managing SGF files, it includes a massive professional-game library, a strong KataGo engine, and polished recording tools. You can study master games, play the AI, and cleanly record your own over-the-board games, all in one place. Our other sponsor is BadukPop, an app that makes Go simple and fun to learn through interactive puzzles, short lessons, and an AI tutor that helps you improve wherever you are. It also provides daily ranked problems that adjust to your level, themed sets such as life-and-death and tesuji, plus AI and online play so you can practice and test what you have learned. Visit badukpop.com. That is B-A-D-U-K-P-O-P dot com.